Key Aspects:
- Royal Caribbean boasts the largest, most advanced ships in the world.
- Carnival Cruise Line fares can be markedly cheaper than Royal Caribbean’s.
- Both lines are family-friendly, but Royal Caribbean caters to a more diverse crowd.
When it comes to booking your first cruise, many cruisers end up comparing and contrasting two of the largest cruise lines in the business: Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean.
While they have their similarities, these cruise lines also have major differences, such as ship size, demographic, pricing, and more, and thus choosing the right option of the two is key to having an enjoyable vacation.
Carnival is ideal for an affordable getaway. Royal Caribbean has bigger ships. Carnival is low-key with plentiful complimentary dining options. Royal Caribbean may cost more, but you may find the quality of food and entertainment to be superior.
Let’s dive into these differences and others, so if you’re deciding between Carnival and Royal Caribbean, you can feel confident booking your best fit.
In This Article:
Quick Comparison of Royal Caribbean vs Carnival Cruise Line
| Category | Royal Caribbean | Carnival Cruise Line |
| Overall vibe | Modern, contemporary, and tech-forward, with lots of “first at sea” attractions and perks | Low key, casual and, depending on the itinerary, party focused |
| Guests Demographics | Lots of options, but fewer complementary options | Families, budget travelers, young adults |
| Fares | Not as high as what you’ll get with a luxury cruise line, but definitely higher, especially on new ships | Some of the most affordable fares in the industry |
| Fleet and ship size | Royal Caribbean boasts the largest ships in the world, with 29 ships in the fleet | Not small, but not the largest ships in the world either, with 29 ships in the fleet |
| Cabins | More variety to choose from, and more unique options | Basic and traditional |
| Dining | Large number of high-quality activities for all ages, from waterparks and zip lines to ice skating and ropes courses, plus theatrical and live music entertainment | Modern, contemporary and tech-forward, with lots of “first at sea” attractions and perks |
| Entertainment and Activities | Perfect Day at CocoCay; Royal Beach Club, Paradise Island; Labadee, Haiti; and a future Mexico destination | Lots of options, and many are complimentary and crowd favorites |
| Private destinations | Waterslides, deck parties, the first rollercoaster at sea, comedy shows and a lot of highly reviewed crew member-led activities | Half Moon Cay and Celebration Key |
Ship Size
When comparing Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean based on ship size, the clear winner is Royal Caribbean. The line boasts the biggest vessels in the biz, frequently outdoing itself with record-setting vessels often named the largest cruise ships in the world.
Currently, Royal Caribbean’s Icon class ships and the lead ship, Icon of the Seas, take this title, and they can carry more than 7,500 passengers each at max capacity. The rest of the fleet isn’t too tiny either (though, sure, you can find older, smaller Royal Caribbean ships).

In contrast, Carnival Cruise Line’s ships are slightly smaller. Its biggest ships are Carnival Jubilee and Carnival Celebration, which carry just over 6,600 passengers at max capacity. Again, that’s hardly small, but it definitely drags behind Royal Caribbean.
Does Ship Size Matter to You?
If you’re deciding between a Royal Caribbean cruise and a Carnival Cruise Line cruise, as a newbie, you might not even think about ship size initially. However, the size of the ship you cruise on will really impact your trip experience.
The bigger the ship, the more amenities (and often the newer the ship, with more innovation). However, on the flip side of that, you also get more crowds.
You’ll want to weigh the pros and cons before deciding what’s best for you.
Fleet Size
In terms of fleet size, or how many overall ships the brand has for you to choose from when booking, both Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line are very similar.
Royal Caribbean has 29 ships, ranging from Star of the Seas, which first set sail in 2025, to Grandeur of the Seas, which dates back to 1996. Furthermore, Royal Caribbean will welcome more ships to its family in both 2026 and 2027, with the arrivals of Legend of the Seas and Hero of the Seas.

Carnival’s fleet, meanwhile, consists of 29 ships, ranging from the newest in the bunch, Carnival Jubilee, which debuted in 2023, to the oldest, Carnival Sunshine, which debuted in 1996. Carnival Cruise Line likewise will welcome new ships in the coming years, with Carnival Festivale in 2027 and Carnival Tropicale in 2028.
Cruise Fares
One big deciding factor for a lot of people when booking a cruise? The cost. Cruising can be very economical, but some lines are more affordable than others.
In general, Carnival Cruise Line keeps up a reputation as being, if not the most affordable cruise line overall, definitely one of the top most affordable options for most, before you even consider any discounts or specials.

Royal Caribbean’s fares are often higher, especially when you get into the newer, larger ships.
As with everything in travel, though, you get what you pay for. I love getting a great deal on a cruise, but I also definitely don’t mind splurging, especially if it means I’m going to enjoy a top tier cruising experience, whether that be because the ship is brand new, I’m staying in a luxury suite, etc.
Cabins and Suites
And on that note, how do the cabins and suites on Carnival Cruise Line vs. Royal Caribbean compare?
This is ultimately going to really come down to the actual ship that you’re on and which cabin you book. While, yes, often Royal Caribbean’s ships will offer more variety in terms of staterooms and cabins, as well as more unique options, such as the Ultimate Family Suite or staterooms with virtual balconies, a newer ship is just about always going to offer better cabins than an older one.

You’ll also notice a difference in overall cabin aesthetic across the two brands. Carnival’s cabins are typically bright and cheery, and make you feel like you’re at, say, an all inclusive resort in the Caribbean. Royal Caribbean’s aesthetic is a little more subdued and leans toward an upscale hotel vibe.
Dining
Long time cruisers of Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean have established fan favorite dining venues across the lines. You definitely won’t go hungry on either.
Carnival, though, typically delivers more in terms of complimentary dining, whereas Royal Caribbean offers a lot of truly amazing dining experiences (like the new supper club style eateries on its newer ships) … but for an extra cost if you’re branching too far away from the main dining room.

Honestly, if you’re a foodie traveler who doesn’t mind paying extra, I’d recommend you consider Royal Caribbean. If you just want good, but cheap, eats, go for Carnival and indulge in fast (free!) favorites like Guy’s Burger Joint.
Activities and Entertainment
Royal Caribbean really goes all out when it comes to entertainment, with tons of remarkable, first at sea attractions.
There are the basic Royal Caribbean fun offerings, that you’ll see on the majority of the line’s ships, like FlowRider surfing simulators and rock climbing walls, but also features like the next generation SeaPlex, the largest indoor and outdoor activity space at sea, and the Category 6 waterpark with its six slides.

Carnival Cruise Line, though, is none too shabby when it comes to the entertainment and activities arena. From ropes courses and a water park, to the SkyRide and the world’s first roller coaster at sea, dubbed BOLT, the line’s newest ships really deliver.
Just, again, keep in mind: The bigger and newer the ship, the more entertainment. It would be unfair to compare a 20 year old Royal Caribbean ship to a brand new Carnival ship and vice versa.
Demographic
So who will you be sailing alongside, on these two lines?
Both cruise lines are very family-friendly. Still, because Carnival Cruise Line is typically always cheaper, you may find the demographics skew younger. Especially on shorter itineraries, don’t be surprised to see college students and/or young adults looking for a fun time.
In contrast, the Royal Caribbean demographic is a little more diverse and spread out among age groups.
Private Destinations
Both Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean have a handful of private destinations, where cruisers can enjoy branded experiences and everything from private beaches to zip lining, eco tours to beachside dining.
Royal Caribbean has its Perfect Day at CocoCay, in the Bahamas, with its waterpark, the largest freshwater pool in the Caribbean, and adults-only spaces. Then, there’s a Haitian private destination called Labadee with multiple beaches and zip lining; however, it is currently shut down due to security concerns.

Another Bahamas private locale is the Royal Beach Club, Paradise Island, which opened in 2025 with even more to love, spread out over 17 acres, including multiple pools, beaches and the world’s largest swim up bar.
Royal Caribbean is expanding its lineup of private destinations, too, with Perfect Day Mexico coming in 2027.
Carnival Cruise Line, meanwhile, has its Half Moon Cay in the Bahamas, with tons of tours, so that you can get active and go adventuring, whether that means snorkeling, visiting the stingrays, biking, etc.
It likewise also opened up a new destination in 2025: Celebration Key. It features a huge freshwater lagoon, adults only areas and dining options.
Itineraries
When it comes to itineraries, both Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line offer a truly astounding number of options, all across the world. Whether you want to cruise the Caribbean, Alaska, Europe, etc., you can do it (and you can book that cruise on CruiseHive!).

To be honest, unless you have your heart set on a very, very specific itinerary or on leaving out of a specific, small port, I wouldn’t let itineraries determine whether you sail on Royal Caribbean or Carnival Cruise Line.
Unless you have something extremely specific in mind, chances are high that you’ll be able to find an itinerary that suits your needs with either of these lines.
Which is Best: Carnival Cruise Line or Royal Caribbean?
Ultimately, I can’t tell you if Carnival Cruise Line or Royal Caribbean is “the best,” out of the two. It’s all going to depend on who you are as a traveler and what kind of experience you’re looking for.
If you want something really budget-friendly, and money is your main concern, then sure, go with Carnival. If you want to sail on some of the biggest, newest, most advanced ships in the world, Royal Caribbean’s new megaships may be for you. Looking for a party atmosphere? Try Carnival.
Booking a multigenerational trip and want a cruise line that offers a little bit of something for everyone, regardless of age? Royal Caribbean delivers.
Don’t just take my word for it, though. If there’s any group of travelers that’s outspoken about their experiences, no punches pulled, it’s cruisers. You can find tons of people comparing and contrasting Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean on forums like Reddit
For example, a recent Reddit post contrasted the two after the original poster sailed on both three times. Their verdict? The food is comparable, but Carnival wins thanks to poolside options, while Royal Caribbean’s entertainment is of a higher quality.
Another Reddit thread succinctly summed up the difference as “Carnival is Walmart and Royal Caribbean is Target.” That’s a viewpoint that I can definitely agree with.








