LNG Cruise Ship: Top Pros and Cons

While there is plenty of excitement surrounding the reduced emissions of an LNG cruise ship, there are both pros and cons of this type of fuel.

Affiliate Disclaimer

With cruise ships being under pressure to become more environmentally friendly and reduce their carbon footprint, the cruise industry has been looking for alternative energy sources for many years now.

The ongoing search for a sustainable fuel source has been accelerated over the past few years and is now showing up on LNG cruise ships.

One of the most notable changes involves the shift to using liquefied natural gas (LNG) to power cruise ships. The first LNG ship was Carnival-owned AIDAnova in 2018. Since then, 20 LNG-powered cruise ships have come to market.

What Is Liquified Natural Gas?

Generally, natural gas tends to come from a fossil source. However, it can also be produced from the decomposition of waste products. Natural gas is extracted from the earth’s core and is cooled to -260°F, making it liquified gas. It is mostly methane but is only referred to as LNG once it has been liquified. This is done by either pressurization or refrigeration.

Aidanova LNG Cruise Ship
Photo: Aida Cruises

Refrigeration is usually the chosen method for its safety and ease of non-pressurized storage and transport. In a liquified state, it is colorless, odorless, non-toxic, non-corrosive, and cost-effective when compared to petroleum or gas. Plus, it is cleaner and easier to use in engines, requiring less maintenance time.

Turning this gas into a liquid is necessary since it reduces its volume to 1/600th of natural gas in a gaseous state. If it is not turned into a liquified state, a ship’s fuel tanks would be so large that you wouldn’t be able to carry anything on board.

Advantages of an LNG Cruise Ship

Liquefied natural gas is a clean-burning fuel that cuts sulfur emissions up to 99% and nitrogen oxide emissions by 85%. The overall effect is reducing greenhouse emissions by 30%, thereby eliminating particulate matter from the ship’s exhaust. It has a low environmental impact because sulfur is removed in the pre-liquefaction process.

LNG Vessel
LNG Vessel

This means that it releases almost no particulate matter or sulfur oxides when burned. It also releases less nitrogen oxide and carbon dioxide compared to other fossil fuels.

LNG is safe since its specific gravity is lighter than that of air and it easily diffuses. This means there is a lower risk of explosion. Another advantage is that it will be a stable supply for over 50 years.

The key advantages of LNG are:

  • Less wear and tear on an engine
  • Lower cost
  • Cleaner emissions
  • No need to install scrubber systems 
  • Not necessary to pay higher price for a low sulphur fuel

Disadvantages of LNG Cruise Ship

The downside to an LNG-powered ship is that LNG is a fossil fuel, which is finite. Some people estimate that with the current rate of consumption, the natural gas reserves may only last another 50 years. If we assume that additional legacy marine fuels will also become scarcer, we may find ourselves looking for another solution.

Costa Smeralda
Costa Smeralda

Engine Requirements

One disadvantage to this marine fuel is that it can’t be used in existing diesel or gas engines. Cruise ships need to be built using a specific engine type so as much LNG can be held as possible and it is able to burn properly.

With the lower fuel density, any LNG-fueled cruise ship requires twice the tank space. This may cost the cruise ship a few cabins, meaning fewer paying passengers.

Absence of Fueling Depots

There aren’t many fueling facilities currently in existence, so getting an LNG-powered cruise ship refueled takes planning. Although there are plans to create additional LNG fueling depots, many ships are hesitant to make the switch at present. They are willing to pay more for maintenance costs and extra fuel in exchange for the ability to easily refuel.

LNG Fueling
LNG Fueling

Some cruise ships are equipped to default to diesel fuel if they run out of their primary fuel source or if the engines fail and they aren’t close to a fueling facility.

The main disadvantages to LNG are:

  • The cost for new construction is 15-30% higher when compared to ships that operate on conventional fuel
  • Capital is needed for equipment outside of engines. This includes fuel tanks that are two to three times bigger than conventional tanks, plus reliquefaction equipment
  • The engines must be equipped to use the fuel
  • The current lack of fueling depots may be a deterrent

The good news may be in the fact that there are other options that have some potential. These include biofuels, ammonia, hydrogen, and potentially nuclear power. However, as with most fuels, each comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

What Might the Future Look Like?

It has become apparent that electricity will likely play a significant role in future fuel sources. This may not be a huge surprise when you consider innovations in battery storage in recent years. There have also been advancements in this field in the automotive industry, making the introduction to the cruise sector more plausible.

Yet cruise ships seem to be on a different scale in comparison to everything else. Batteries, while they may work, are heavy, which is a large consideration when you consider that a ship must remain afloat. This means that mega-ships will probably not be exclusively powered by electricity anytime soon.

P&O Iona Cruise Ship in the UK
Photo Credit: Peter Titmuss / Shutterstock.com

While companies like Eco Sightseeing are using Tesla batteries to convert a passenger boat to electrical propulsion, using this technology on a larger scale would involve incorporating 10,000 Tesla S85 batteries daily. Yet, as batteries become smaller with an expanded capacity, this may be plausible in the future.

One such example is the Yangtze River Three Gorges 1, which has been named the largest electric cruise ship in the world.  It recently completed its maiden voyage from the home port of Yichang in China’s Hubei Province. The ship is 100 meters in length and has zero emissions.

It can carry 1,300 passengers in a single voyage and is electrically powered by batteries with a total of 7,500kWh (100 EVs).

While these advancements are promising, the ships can only run for short durations and aren’t suitable for long voyages.

Conclusion

LNG cruise ships have both benefits and disadvantages despite the rosy picture that is often depicted. While they do have less harmful emissions, the cost of implementing them, in addition to the lack of bunkering facilities, has served as a deterrent for some time.

However, with the desire to become more environmentally friendly, many cruise lines are making the move to LNG-powered vessels.

Haiyan Ma
Haiyan Ma
I absolutely love cruising with my favorite ports of call being in the Caribbean. As a former crew member for Disney Cruise Line, Royal Caribbean, and Carnival Cruise Line I can continue my passion by sharing my experiences with readers. Find out more about us here.

CRUISE HIVE NEWSLETTER

Expert cruise tips and news! We'll send you weekly newsletters to your inbox with the latest cruise news and tips.

Choose from over 30 Travel Insurance plans to find your best option
128 Shares
128 Shares